The Inn at 2nd & C

Beautiful historical hotel in downtown Eureka. The rooms are lovely. Jeffrey and the other staff are outstanding. This was my third time staying here and it’s always been very enjoyable. I was sorry to learn that the restaurant on the ground floor had closed but there are plenty of other places to eat that are within walking distance.

It was such a cool atmosphere! I took plenty of pictures because it's definitely worth a stay for the experience. The staff was friendly and helpful. The room was clean and nicely furnished, I would 10/10 recommend. I do like that their is security at night as well!

The hotel is cute and if you like historic places you will enjoy the charm and history. Our room was nice and big, as was the bathroom. Not sure I loved the big red bathtub without a shower curtain. Overall, I found the place a bit stuffy even though it's clean and well maintained. Due to the location downtown and close to the water, it was a bit noisy at night. I don't know Eureka well but it didn't seem like the best area of town. The hotel is in walking distance to downtown shops and the visitor center. as well as restaurants and the water front. The staff was very friendly and helpful to us. Thank you! I also enjoyed being able to use the yoga room for free.

Unsafe location here with a homeless shelter next-door. Car alarm going off during the night as homeless were in the parking lot. You needed security guard to go to car after dark. Did not sleep all night. Checked out a night early and they would not refund our second night. In fact, the front desk was actually nasty. Be safe, stay somewhere else!

This was such a treat. We have been on the road for almost 2 weeks and were so tired of cookie cutter hotels. This one has an amazing Wild West feel to it with beautiful ornate wood work everywhere. It is easy to imagine how this would have looked back in the day.

No AC. Rooms expensive with no comforts. Time warp and not in a good way.. This place was horrible! It was a bad experience all around. Unfortunately, I trusted the reviews of TripAdvisor and it bit me hard! I’m just going to say this ain’t my cup of tea and can’t wait to checkout!!

Super cool aesthetic with amazing restaurant food, and the rooms were very clean and unique. Only downfalls were the lack of a variety at breakfast (only given how amazing the food was at the restaurant, the breakfast seemed very lackluster - just bagels and small pastries) and being woken up each morning by homeless people. Otherwise it was a great stay and encouraged my family to try more historic hotels!

This hotel was very special; we had a fun and comfortable stay. All the small details were on point- a French press and hot water kettle in the room and great bath products. Bed was very comfortable and the vintage decor was next level. Amazing food at the hotel restaurant…

The hotel is from 1888 and you need to REALLY keep that in mind! There is no TV, no microwave, no coffee in room( or available except in the morning), no blinds on the windows to keep out the light, no fridge in room, etc... just a basic 1888 room. It looks charming online, and it has its charm, but when compared to the missing comforts, nah. Once you arrive and take a look at the room, too bad for you! There is no " manager available " to "allow " you to get any type of refund or partial refund! Yep, you should have known everything about it by looking at the site online!! I have a medical condition that requires certain accommodations, and apparently that isn't a reasonable cause for any refund at all. We finally left to go pay for another hotel room, after no time in their hotel. We asked the clerk to discuss the refund or partial refund with his manager in the morning when he saw him and let us know! The clerk seemed to have no ability to be flexible in this, I totally fault the manager in the policy, so be warned! My companion made the reservation and I felt very, very bad that his credit card was hit for the absolutely unused room charge! I would NOT recommend this hotel, except for as a quick walk in if you are interested in seeing the architecture.