Stone Soup Inn

Friendly and helpful staff. The property and stay were above and beyond my expectations. I would definitely stay here again

David is a brilliant host with terrific knowledge of the local area for dining and entertainment suggestions. A gorgeous old home that is a destination in itself.

This was a great place to stay. The innkeeper was amazing. We were able to walk to the Gainbridge Fieldhouse for a concert (30 min walk) and to dinner. It was quiet, clean and unique!

Great place

beautiful classic colonial home. beautiful inside. a variety of options in terms of rooms. David the innkeeper was very helpful. very friendly and represents the property well. easy drive to downtown from location. great restaurants in the neighborhood. thoroughly enjoyed my stay and will definitely be back.

This was our first time here. Everything and everyone was lovely. It’s a beautiful property and lose to so many things in Indy.

The house is absolutely gorgeous and the staff is warm and inviting. The neighborhood is charming. However, the breakfast, though beautifully staged, was no better than a continental breakfast at a budget hotel.

B&B Wanna Be: The lovely structure holds surprises and disappointments. We called from the west side of Cincinnati saying we’d arrive in an hour 40 minutes, according to our map, and so we did, expecting the host to greet us. Nope. No one around. So we called and found he was elsewhere and would come right away, which took 5-10 minutes. We checked into our room, the Victorian room, which has some lovely elements but mostly is just someone had a delightful time painting geometrics from top to bottom. Rather fun, but “Victorian”? He showed us the dining area where we could eat breakfast in the morning, a continental breakfast. Huh? Isn’t the second “b” in B&B mean breakfast? I read on ******* and TripAdvisor “breakfast included.” He said breakfast would be served from 7-9 in the morning and he would be there throughout that time. Just come on down whenever. We walked to supper, and hour downtown, guaranteed that walking even in the dark is “perfectly safe.” We enjoyed our evening. Night noise: well, 4-6 huge metal plates for some construction on the road are stretched across the somewhat busy road and bus route just outside our windows, and so a deep clank-clank would resound for each vehicle passing over, the frequent buses giving a bonus clank, but at least they stop running from midnight until 5 to enable us 5 lovely hours of sleep on a super soft almost saggy mattress. We went down for breakfast at 7:30. No one around. We searched. No one. We called the guy, and he was surprised and was wondering why his motion alarm for the room was going off. He’d be there in 15 minutes, he said. Not acceptable, we replied, and returned to our room to finish packing and head out to continue our road trip. A few minutes later we were about to open the front door to head out when he called from the dining room and in a flurry offered us muffins, apples, and yogurt, while inviting us to sit down and enjoy. We took some of what he offered and hit the road. During our stay, whatever it was, he had higher priorities than his guests, by far. We’d get better service and an equivalent breakfast at a cheap motel along the road somewhere.

This is a beautiful old home that allows the visitor to take a step back into history. The staff works double-time to make sure you live your stay. They succeeded.